I just finished reading Sax Rohmer's
The Insidious Dr. Fu Manchu.
Wow. What racist garbage this is. It starts off as a bad Sherlock Holmes knock off. There's Inspector Nayland Smith who has many of the characteristics and habits of Holmes, and he has his Watson, too, except this one is named Dr. Petrie. Okay. I can live with knock offs as long as they're well written. This one isn't. The writing is downright bad. Way too many adverbs and purple melodrama make this damn near unreadable. And the plot is bad. The characters are idiots. They get caught in a trap door the first time they confront the Doctor. Okay, cool. But then they get caught by the same trap later on in the book! Well, you can't blame the characters. That's just lousy goddamn writing.
But it's the blatant racism that appalls. I'm of two minds about this as a writer. I don't hold it against Edgar Rice Burroughs he had some ignorance in his books when it came to minorities, anymore than I hold it against Ian Fleming or Conan Doyle or other writers in the past. They are for the most part reflecting their culture at the time and not so much speaking what's in their heart. At least they told good stories.
Sax Rohmer, on the other hand, is a downright racist even for 1913. This book is
filled with racism. He's not only reflecting attitudes of his time, he's showing you what's in his heart. Rohmer is always jabbering about the war between the white race and the yellow race. He calls them "Yellow Hordes", "Yellow Demons", and finds every possible way to couple the world "yellow" with a less-than-flattering description. It never stops; the book is filled with phrases like that and it's unrelenting.
And it's a real shame because Dr. Fu Manchu is a pretty decent character. Evil to the bone, he might be some ancient force who inhabited the body of a hapless human, usurping its soul. Kinda neat. And he uses science and biology to further his evil ends and sustain his criminal empire. Lots to work with there, right? Wrong. As far as Rohmer is concerned Fu Manchu is nothing but an extension of the dangerous yellow race that is plotting to destroy and enslave (or is it enslave and destroy, I forget) the fine, upstanding, God-fearing white race. Cut and dried. Q. E. D.
For all its faults there are a couple of good things that caught my eye. Nayland Smith is never more than a caricature, and badly rendered one, of Sherlock Holmes. But Dr. Petrie has his moments, especially when he meets and falls in love with Fu Manchu's Egyptian slave, Karamaneh. She's good, too, and apparently later on in the series they marry.
Does that surprise you? Yes, it's a series. This book was so popular Rohmer wrote a ton of these friggin' things. People ate them up.
As I said, it's too bad. There were lots of opportunities for this to be a great book rather than a vile, racist tract. In the hands of a better writer it might have been. I have no plans to read any more of these. One was enough, thank you, very much. And, no, I can't recommend this book at all. Read it at your own peril.
And speaking of peril, yellow or otherwise, as perceived by the estimable Sax Rohmer, he died of the Asian Flu. No, really. After all his novels spouting this racist crap, he was eventually done in by the Asian Flu.
And that, my friends, is the meaning of irony.