As good as it was, George Romero's
Night of the Living Dead has done more to destroy the zombie genre than any other movie or book I can think of.
And that's not a good thing. Here's why.
Prior to this zombies were never about eating people. And they sure as hell were never about eating brains. God knows where that got started. But here's the problem with Romero's film. It took what was once a genre filled with mystique and made it into splatter-chomp. And now that it's splatter-chomp there was nowhere else for it go go except over-hyped splatter-chomp cum Apocalypse. Now served with brains on the side. And it wasn't long before the genre devolved (yes, devolved, imo) into slapstick and parody. Now we have zombies no one can take seriously. That's what faces us today.
It's too bad, really, because zombies had so much going for them prior to Romero's film. Take Bela Lugosi's
White Zombie. That was an awesome film. So was Val Lewton's uber-supreme
I Walked with a Zombie which used Jane Eyre as source material.
Val Lewton's take on Jane Eyre...with zombies, voodoo, pathos, and Gothic imagery
These movies and others like them portrayed zombies for what they were supposed to be: living people (and sometimes dead, you couldn't always tell) transformed into the unliving. Usually to serve as slaves or to make them pay for some horrible crime. But there was always something poignant about the zombie and its plight in these movies. There's nothing poignant about the modern flesh eating zombie. He's a cartoon.
Okay, he didn't start off that way. I concede that. Romero's film was both horrifying and artistic with a steady dose of nihilism. He was making a deeper statement about the world he saw and he just happened to use zombies to get his point across. But lesser filmmakers, and writers, only saw the cannibalism and ran with that single idea. And now we're left with zombies eating brains and there's nowhere else for them to go.
No pun intended, but, imo, that's a dead end, artistic-wise. Better to have examined the deep mystery, the Gothic imagery combined with Carribean mysticism of zombiedom, rather than turning zombies into fast food consumers.
Be truthful. Zombies as they are now portrayed are no longer frightening or horrific. They're gross. I'll give you that. But they're not scary.
So in my opinion the zombie genre is in bad straits. I hope someone comes along soon and reboots it with an eye toward reviving its mystical past. If they can reboot Star Trek and Spider-Man then they should be able to reboot this. Anyway, I hope so, 'cuz I kinda like zombies. The old time zombies. The cool zombies. The mystical zombies. The
scary ones.
Until this happens, where can you go to read good, memorable zombie stories? Look no further than Marvel's
Tales of the Zombie. This was a black and white comic published in the Seventies and it rocks. It's what zombies used to be about. It's sexy and violent and Simon Garth, the zombie in question, is cool. The only carp I have is it's written in second person, a forced literary affectation I have always despised because it calls too much attention to itself. But even so the artwork and characterization overcomes that limitation.
If, like me, you miss the old time zombies then check out this collection. I think you'll like it.
